Rings Of Power's Most Controversial Season 2 Moment Continues A Frustrating Tolkien Debate (2024)

A particular moment in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power has inspired a fiery debate—but such a topic is really nothing new to Tolkien's Lord of the Rings. Some of the most controversial aspects of the Prime Video series revolve around changes made to canon, and the same is true for this season 2 moment. There's the implication of a romance that was never described by Tolkien and, therefore, seems to break apart the established story fans know and love. However, the grey area that Rings of Power built into this scene fits right in with similar relationships in the Lord of the Rings.

The moment in question is, of course, the big kiss scene between Elrond and Galadriel in Rings of Power season 2, episode 7. Galadriel had been captured by Adar's forces, and Elrond was unwilling to trade the Elvish Ring of Power, Nenya, for her freedom. However, he was granted an opportunity to say goodbye, and the two Elves shared a rather tender and stirring kiss. After pulling away, Elrond placed a pin in Galadriel's hand, which she could (and did) use to escape. However, the big question and debate is whether this Rings of Power moment was romance or just a moment of deep friendship.

Elrond & Galadriel's Rings Of Power Kiss Has Sparked A Heated Debate

Is It Romance Or A Strong Friendship?

Since Elrond passed Galadriel a pin during their big kiss in Rings of Power season 2, it can easily be argued that the "romantic" moment was just a cover-up. However, others have said that Elrond could have used virtually any other means of distraction to help Galadriel escape and that he chose a kiss because of genuine affection for her. The debate here has been ongoing, and the fact that such a kiss was never described in Lord of the Rings canon has made these arguments all the fierier.

Still, the foundation of this debate is really nothing new. Sure, there was never a question about Elrond and Galadriel's relationship in Tolkien's works, but Rings of Power season 2 has effectively reintroduced the very same question that modern audiences have asked of nearly every Lord of the Rings friendship—are they romantic or just really affectionate buddies.

Tolkien's Friendships Have Always Been Romance Coded

Rings Of Power Has Continued The Trend

Friendships in Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings have always come with a great deal of physical and poetic affection. The author brings attention to the physical moments between Frodo and Sam, from holding hands to embracing. What's more, they would often describe their love to one another, and there wasn't much difference between these poetic exclamations and those of genuine romances like Aragorn and Arwen or Beren and Luthien. The same is true for Legolas and Gimli, whose love was so strong that the Dwarf was the first of his kind ever to be welcomed to the Undying Lands alongside his friend.

While these relationships are presented as friendships, that extra level of affection has inspired endless debates regarding whether Tolkien secretly intended for Frodo and Sam or Legolas and Gimli to appear romantic. It's an argument that will, frustratingly, never come with a definitive answer, and it seems Rings of Power has kept this same energy going with Elrond and Galadriel. It seems unlikely that Prime Video will ever have a clear answer about whether their big kiss was intended as romantic or friendly, and that's pretty perfect for The Lord of the Rings.

Elrond's Kiss Doesn't Make Perfect Sense (But It Works For Lord Of The Rings)

The Lord Of The Rings Themes Tie It All Together

There are still frustrating elements involved with Elrond and Galadriel's kiss, one way or another. Elrond could indeed have worked out a different way to distract Adar and the Orcs aside from laying one on his friend. Moreover, it could also be argued that Prime Video was being purposely inflammatory by including this moment, knowing that such a change in Rings of Power would create negative buzz. Still, there's no way to prove this, especially since the big romantic debate here fits so well with other relationships Tolkien himself created.

One way or another, it's clear that Elrond loves Galadriel, whether as a potential love interest or a very dear friend. Canon dictates that he will end up with Galadriel's daughter, Celebrian, so there is no question whether the connection between these characters in Rings of Power is endgame. Instead, it's just another relationship to add to those that have already been heatedly debated for decades.

See Also

Celebrimbor Eerily Predicts Sauron's One Ring & The Lord Of The Rings' Ending

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

7/10

432

8.4/10

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

Adventure

Fantasy

Action

Drama

Set in the Second Age of Middle-earth, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power explores the forging of the iconic rings, the rise of the Dark Lord Sauron, and the epic events leading up to the stories in J.R.R. Tolkien's classic novels. The series chronicles the creation of legendary characters and the historic alliances and rivalries that shape the fate of Middle-earth.

Where to Watch

Season

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US

Cast

Morfydd Clark , Charlie Vickers , Charles Edwards , Markella Kavenagh , Daniel Weyman , Ismael Cruz Cordova , Megan Richards , Robert Aramayo , Robert Strange , Cynthia Addai-Robinson , Lloyd Owen , Owain Arthur , Tyroe Muhafidin , Alex Tarrant , Benjamin Walker , Trystan Gravelle , Maxim Baldry , Sophia Nomvete , Ema Horvath , Nazanin Boniadi , Geoff Morrell , Peter Mullan , Sara Zwangobani , Lenny Henry , Leon Wadham , Dylan Smith , Thusitha Jayasundera , Maxine Cunliffe , Anthony Crum , Beau Cassidy , Joseph Mawle , Peter Tait , Sam Hazeldine , Bridie Sisson , Jed Brophy , Ciarán Hinds , Amelia Kenworthy , Kevin Eldon

Character(s)

Galadriel , Halbrand , Lord Celebrimbor , Nori Brandyfoot , The Stranger , Arondir , Poppy Proudfellow , Elrond , Glûg , Queen Regent Míriel , Captain Elendil , Prince Durin IV , Theo , Valandil , High King Gil-galad , Pharazôn , Isildur , Princess Disa , Eärien , Bronwyn , Waldreg , King Durin III , Marigold Brandyfoot , Sadoc Burrows , Kemen , Largo Brandyfoot , Malva , Vilma , Ontamo , Dilly Brandyfoot , Adar , Tredwill , The Dweller , Vrath , Dark Wizard , Mirdania , Narvi

Release Date

September 1, 2022

Seasons

3

Network

Amazon Prime Video

Streaming Service(s)

Amazon Prime Video

Franchise(s)

The Lord of the Rings

Writers

Patrick McKay , John D. Payne , J.R.R. Tolkien , Justin Doble , Jason Cahill , Gennifer Hutchison , Stephany Folsom , Nicholas Adams

Directors

J.A. Bayona , Sanaa Hamri

Showrunner

John D. Payne , Patrick McKay , Louise Hooper , Charlotte Brändström , Wayne Yip

Main Genre

Fantasy